|
Walter de Gruyter: Berlin, 1996. 3-11-012990-6. (First English edition of Symmetrien der Natur. Walter de Gruyter: Berlin, 1988.) 659 pp + 20 pp. Index.
Mainzer's work is what it advertises itself to be: a
compendious handbook of discoveries of symmetries,
particularly in mathematics and the natural sciences, and
their representation in theories, in philosophy of science, and
to a lesser degree in technology and broader culture.
Among over a hundred distinguishable areas of study
considered are, for example, the following: illustrations and a
cursory discussion of symmetrical art from Navajo, Aztec,
Indian, and Chinese sources; a few pages on the mechanism of
the ancient Chinese south-pointing carriage; twenty pages
on the history of constructions of regular polygons and
Platonic and other geometric solids; symmetries in historical and
recent space-time theories and in thermodynamics and
chaotic systems; antisymmetry in DNA synthesis and
structural symmetries and asymmetries in organisms; and
even metaphorical "symmetry breaking" in decentered
postmodern art and critical theory.
Symmetry has become a particularly important
topic in philosophy of science, especially since the publication
by Bas C. van Fraassen of Laws and Symmetry
(Clarendon: Oxford, 1989.). Van Fraassen argues that the idea of
necessity that underlies law explanation and causation is a
vestige of 17th century science, and an account of science as
a process of constructing models that express
mathematical relations, symmetries, and invariances provides
adequate representation of the phenomena of nature. Mainzer's
interest lies in a related project, determining the
prospects for a unification of theories among the sciences, or the
unification of models. His collection represents a useful
resource for those attempting to understand the prospects
for unification and the degree to which symmetry
arguments pervade scientific explanation across fields. Mainzer is
a philosopher of mathematics and physics, and his
extended discussion of physics, especially quantum mechanics
and particles, is the most developed portion of the volume,
and provides a core that connects a good deal, though not all,
of the balance of the handbook. Consequently, chemistry
is considered primarily in a 30-page historical treatment
of crystal classification, leading to a discussion of
mathematical group theory, and molecular handedness.
Homochirality in nature also comes in for brief treatment. A short
discussion of molecular structures introduces the topic of the
prospects and purposes of a unification of theories by a
reduction of stereochemistry to quantum mechanics, given
that "our models and images are always only more or less
drastic simplifications and abstractions of complex
relationships" in nature itself.
|